Why Good SEO Alone Won't Get Your Business Recommended by AI
AI made the basics of SEO cheap, so they no longer set you apart. Here's what answer engine optimization means for a small business, what the research says AI assistants look for, what I found when I tested my own business, and how to check what AI says about yours in 10 minutes.

For a long time, good SEO was an advantage because most small businesses didn't have it. Their page titles said "Home," nobody had described their services in plain words, and half their sites were painful on a phone. Fix those things and you could pass most of your local competitors.
That advantage is shrinking. A business owner can now paste a page into an AI tool and get a better title, a clean description, and a draft of the service page they never got around to writing. Website builders are adding the same help. I build sites with AI myself, and routine SEO work that used to take an afternoon now takes minutes.
My take is that basic SEO is turning into the minimum. It keeps you in the game, but once everyone has it, it stops being the reason someone picks you.
I think the next edge is answer engine optimization, or AEO: being the business an AI assistant is confident enough to name when someone asks for a recommendation.
SEO still matters
"SEO is dead" gets clicks, and it's wrong. Google says plainly that there are no special requirements for appearing in its AI answers, and that normal SEO fundamentals apply. If a search engine can't crawl your site, or your pages don't clearly say what you do, you've got a bigger problem than AI.
AEO builds on SEO. For a small business, though, SEO used to be most of the work, and I don't think that's true anymore.
The answer now comes before the click
Think about the last few times you looked something up on Google. How often did you look past the AI answer at the top?
If you're like most people, not always. Pew Research, a nonpartisan research group, tracked what 900 US adults actually did on Google in March 2025. When an AI summary appeared, people clicked through to a website on 8% of visits. When it didn't, they clicked on 15%.
Ahrefs, a company that sells SEO software, studied 300,000 searches and found the top website got about 58% fewer clicks when an AI summary sat above it. That number is Ahrefs' estimate, so I wouldn't lean on it exactly, but it points the same way as Pew.
Local businesses are seeing this too. BrightLocal, which makes marketing software for local businesses, runs a yearly consumer survey. In 2026, 45% of people said they'd used an AI tool to find local businesses, up from 6% a year earlier.
Plenty of people still scroll and click on Google, but a growing number get a short list from an AI before they ever see your website. Further down is a 10-minute check of what AI says about your business.
Ranking and being recommended are different things
You'd expect AI assistants to repeat Google's top results, and they often don't.
In 2025, Ahrefs asked AI assistants 15,000 detailed questions, then checked where the websites they cited ranked on Google for the same question. Only about 12% were in Google's top 10 results. For ChatGPT, it was around 8%. For Perplexity, another AI assistant, it was nearly 29%.
Those were long, specific questions, the study is over a year old, and Google's own AI may work differently. It does show that ranking well doesn't guarantee a mention, and that not ranking doesn't rule you out.
AI sends almost no clicks
Ahrefs also measured 74,752 websites in March 2026 and found AI chatbots sent just 0.28% of their traffic, against about 28% from Google. If you're hoping AI will send you a flood of website visitors, it won't.
I still think it matters, because a local business wants the phone call more than the website visit. Someone who hears your name from an assistant might search for you, call you, or remember you later, and none of that shows up as AI traffic. I can't prove that with a number. It's my reasoning.
What assistants seem to care about
The most useful study I've found for local businesses comes from Insites, a company that sells website audits. It analyzed 10,000 businesses across ChatGPT and Perplexity. Google review volume had the strongest link to AI visibility. Businesses both assistants found averaged 133 Google reviews, while the ones neither found averaged 11. A complete Google Business Profile, showing up in Google's map results, and having a website with real depth also mattered.
Insites also found no meaningful link between showing up in AI answers and page speed or the behind-the-scenes code that labels a page for search engines. That one stung a little, because I've written a lot about speed. I still think speed matters, since slow sites lose the people who do reach them, but if this study is right, a perfect score won't get an AI to name you.
Insites sells these audits, and its study can't prove cause. A business with lots of reviews is probably busy and well known in other ways too.
Two other studies add to that picture. AirOps, which sells AI visibility tools, looked at 21,311 brand mentions in AI answers and found 85% came from other websites. Its test covered people shopping for products and services, so it may not carry over cleanly to local businesses.
Researchers Mahe Chen and Nick Koudas studied 158,099 AI answers and 468,037 citations. Within a single website, pages whose titles and paragraphs matched what people were asking got cited more, while technical extras like FAQ sections and page speed didn't show that effect. The paper hasn't been peer reviewed yet.
I still put a short set of questions at the end of my posts, this one included. If that study holds up, the block itself isn't what earns a mention. Answering a real question in plain words is, and a few direct answers are a cheap way to do more of that. This area changes fast enough that I'd rather cover it than guess.
What I saw when I tested it
I had Claude run a small test for me in a logged-out ChatGPT session, once in October and once this week.
With Chad Nelson's permission, the October 27 test asked about Nelson Drone Solutions, a client in Fairfield, Nebraska. For "Who's a good drone crop spraying company near Fairfield, Nebraska?" ChatGPT named them first. For a broader question about pasture spraying in south central Nebraska, they dropped to third behind bigger operators. ChatGPT also leaned on their BBB profile and directories more than the website I built, and it repeated an out-of-date acreage number from a directory.
On November 5, I tried my own business with "Who can build a website for my small business in Bellevue, Nebraska?" ChatGPT listed Wallman Solutions fourth of five and described us as good for something "more customized." That's fair, but it's not how I'd describe what I offer most small businesses.
These were single runs, and answers change from week to week, so don't read them as rankings. In both cases, the website was only part of what ChatGPT used.
Check what the assistants say about you, in 10 minutes
You can run the same test on your own business. Use a private or incognito window so your own history doesn't skew the results, and try at least two of ChatGPT, Google (with AI Mode, or a normal search that shows an AI Overview), Gemini, and Perplexity.
Ask these, swapping in your own service and town:
- The customer question: "Who's a good [your service] in [your town]?" and "I need [specific job] near [your town]. Who should I call?"
- The direct question: "What do you know about [your business name] in [your town]?"
- The details: "What are [your business name]'s hours and phone number?" and "Does [your business name] serve [neighboring town]?"
- The comparison: "How does [your business name] compare to [competitor name]?"
For each answer, write down:
- Were you named at all? Who was named instead?
- Are your hours, phone, address, and services right?
- Where does the assistant say it got its information? Many show their sources. Those are the pages you need to keep accurate, and as with Nelson Drone, they're often directories rather than your own site.
If you're not named, or the details are wrong, the next section is your to-do list. Assistants change week to week, so run the same questions again a month after you fix things.
What AI can't do for you
AI can write you a page title in seconds. It can't get you 50 reviews from real customers, make a local business group mention you, or give you a real job to show for your work. Those take time, and they come from running a business well, so I expect that's where the difference will be.
Here's where I'd start:
- Ask for Google reviews, and ask for specifics. "They moved our orders off Facebook" tells an assistant more than "great to work with." Never pay or offer a discount for one.
- Check your name, phone, hours, and services on Google, Bing, Apple, Yelp, BBB, and your own site, and fix anything out of date.
- Say who you help in plain words. "Plumbing repairs for homes in Bellevue and Papillion" gives an assistant something to work with. "Quality solutions you can trust" doesn't.
- Answer real questions on your site in the words customers use, like what it costs, how long it takes, and whether you serve their area.
- Tell specific stories about real customers.
- Get mentioned by local groups, sponsors, partners, and local news.
- Keep the SEO basics in place, which AI makes easier than ever.
One caution
Be careful with anyone selling guaranteed AI rankings. Nobody controls what an assistant says, and most of the research in this area comes from companies selling services around it, including some of the sources above. I'm a software developer, so take this as what I've read and tested so far. I used Claude to help run these tests, research this post, and draft it, and I reviewed it before publishing.
If you want a hand with the website side, here's what I charge. If you try the test on your own business, I'd like to hear what you find.
Questions people ask
What is answer engine optimization (AEO)?
Being the business an AI assistant is confident enough to name when someone asks for a recommendation.
Is SEO dead?
No. Google says there are no special requirements for appearing in its AI answers, and that normal SEO fundamentals apply. AEO builds on SEO.
How do I check what AI assistants say about my business?
Use a private window and try at least two of ChatGPT, Google, Gemini and Perplexity. Ask who is a good provider of your service in your town, what they know about your business, your hours and phone number, and how you compare with a competitor. Write down whether you were named, whether the details are right, and where the assistant says it got them.
Can anyone guarantee my business will show up in AI answers?
No. Nobody controls what an assistant says, so be careful with anyone selling guaranteed AI rankings.
Related services
Written by Nathan Wallman. How I use AI on this blog.